|
Respect. Respect the White Man's
automobile! That is what the one word message at the end of Range
Rover's latest advertisement is commanding you to do. (Click here to watch the 30-second
video).
The ad's opening shot is of a city whose buildings are exclusively Thai
temples. Through this mythical Thai city comes an anachronistic
procession straight out of the British Raj, complete with the masses
bowing as the shrouded carriage of royalty passes, borne on the
shoulders of servants. The crowd is generically Southeast Asian with
elements of hilltribe clothing and ornamentation thrown in to achieve
the proper exoticism. Luckily, this semi-exotic, yet very orderly,
throng of people assembled to worship the passing royalty have been
thoughtful enough to leave unobstructed an intersecting street (with
some people even turned, prepared to worship crossing traffic).
As the Range Rover pulls up to
the intersection, the procession stops and the tension mounts. Who will
be given the honor to proceed first? The tension can be seen on the
faces of many people wearing Akha, Lahu and Mien clothing. Finally, a
bejeweled hand emerges from the shroud and motions the Range Rover to
go ahead. Of course, we can assume that it is just the grace and
practicality of the shrouded royalty that motions the Range Rover on.
She probably realizes that her servants will eventually tire of holding
her carriage waiting for the Range Rover to yield.
The scene fades to black as the
ironic message "Respect" dominates the screen. The advertisement then
reminds us that Land Rovers are "the most well-traveled vehicles on
earth."
Are the advertisers bragging
about their ignorance? It would be one thing if in cutting across the
royal procession the Range Rover driver were portrayed as an awkward
but apologetic accidental tourist. In that case his lack of decorum and
understanding of the basic principles of courtesy in human interaction
could be explained, if not excused. Instead, they make a special point
that drivers of Range Rovers plow through mixed-metaphor processions
and ceremonies of the devout the world over.
Before writing this essay, I
showed the Range Rover ad to the Akha and Lahu guys working with me on
this project. I wanted to see what their reaction would be. Confusion
was the consensus: Why are our people bowing to someone riding in
something we have never seen before? What are our people doing down in
the flat land?
Atee, an Akha, then brushed me
aside and replayed the film, stopping in the places that begged
commentary. He treated those sitting around to a delicious dissection
of the incorrect or inappropriate Akha imagery seen in the film, even
surmising the woman in the Chiang Rai Night Bazaar from whom the
filmmakers bought their cheap, knock-off Akha headgear.
The advertisers do not appear to
concern themselves accuracy in displaying these exotic peoples. But,
why would they be concerned? Their market is neither Akhas nor Filipino
girls wearing sloppily adjusted Akha headgear. No, their market is
exactly the self-important would-be adventurer that has established so
many unflattering stereotypes for himself around the world. Of the many
tiresome tourist types one encounters throughout the world's Tourist
Space, the Range Rover tourist deserves special recognition. Instead of
being the curious but unobtrusive observer, the Range Rover tourist is
one who demands (both implicitly and explicitly) that his Tourist Space
bend to meet his needs in ways that, for locals, range from strange to
inconsiderate, with an occasionally offensive. In spite of this, local
tourism officials can not seem to inconvenience themselves enough to
woo him and his money to their locales, which demonstrates the economic
discrepancy between nations as clearly as any numerical indicator.
Sweating and wealthy, our
intrepid Range Rover tourist comes to places such as northern Thailand
decked out in the uniform of all great explorers (khaki shorts/slacks
and a polo shirt), in search of "adventure" which can be molded into
exotic stories of the "primitive," "colorful" or "amazing" tribal
people with which he interacted. Comfortably nestled within the Tourist
Space, never once in remote danger of having an authentic human
interaction, he marches through a tribal village like a king surveying
his kingdom (a colonial surveying his colony might be a more accurate
description). The villagers welcome him, of course, because they are
polite, but even more so because they have come to see him as a way to
augment their meager incomes. Villagers will attempt to make him feel
honored (more inclined to spend money), but they do not genuinely
respect him. Genuine respect derives not from awe for one's automobile,
but from mutual understanding.
 |
 |
Which of these deserves more respect?
|
|
What do you think? Let your opinion be heard.
Vang Her: Not the automobile, but the person. As you can see, these people are happy, and colorful people. Please help them to keep their tradition, culture and religion. I believe that rainbow color is so much better than one color. (02.05.2006, 04:57) Walter Soden: I just wish that I was 1/2 as smart as most of you people (31.10.2006, 03:32) ">');
//-->
: (16.12.2006, 07:47) Walter Soden: I belive that and Oriental people do not deserve any respect. The Oriental people not better than the Europeans and Americans, They are century behind us and should all be bombed. (15.01.2007, 14:24) Matt Saefong: I think people like walter Soden should be tie to a pole and cane until the one bit of brain cell come out. It easy for you as person whom is born with a siver spoon in it mouth and not knowing how real life is. By disrespect our culture and saying what you have? What have you accomplish? Nothing. You Just need to take that stick out of your @$$ . (23.01.2007, 12:07) Matt Saefong: I think people like Walter Soden should be tie to a pole and cane until the one bit of brain cell come out. It’s easy for you as person whom is born with a silver spoon in it mouth and not knowing how real life is. By disrespect our culture and saying what you have, what have you accomplish? Nothing! Move on with your silver spoon stuck up your @$$. Or you can take that spoon out of your @$$. (23.01.2007, 12:14) ">');
//-->
: (14.02.2007, 10:23) ">');
//-->
: (28.03.2007, 10:18) Zeuz, Kueih Jian: Responding to Walter Soden, Please be kind, thoughtful, and respective to other. If you do not respect other, they do not give a shit. God will panish you, and the ancestor will nail you down like Jesus hanging on the cross, and bit you like hell. Then you will learn. (13.08.2008, 01:46) Zeuz, Kueih Jian: Responding to Walter Soden, Please be kind, thoughtful, and respective to other. If you do not respect other, they do not give a shit. God will panish you, and the ancestor will nail you down like Jesus hanging on the cross, and bit you like hell. Then you will learn. (13.08.2008, 01:46)
|